Heated debate as bill to ban open grazing scales second reading in senate

MaTaZ ArIsInG
Dallas, Texas

A bill seeking to establish ranches and prohibit open grazing across the country has passed the second reading at the senate after a heated debate.

The upper legislative chamber passed the bill for a second reading on Wednesday after Titus Zam, the senator representing Benue North-west, led a debate on it.

Nigeria has been experiencing decades-long clashes between farmers and herders.

While leading a debate on the legislation titled ‘A Bill for an Act to establish National Animal Husbandry and Ranches Commission for the regulation, management, preservation, and control of ranches throughout Nigeria; and for connected purposes, 2024’, Zam said an outright ban on open grazing would stop clashes between herders and farmers.

The Benue senator said ranches should be established in states that have pastoralist communities.

However, Zam’s argument was met with opposition from some northern senators.

Danjuma Goje, senator representing Gombe central, said ranches should not be established in only states that have herders.

Goje argued that laws should not be made for a particular set of people.

“We should be magnanimous enough not to confine them. That will not solve the problem,” he said.

“These people are Nigerians and don’t benefit from anything, they don’t benefit from school, hospitals, or anything.”

Kicking against the bill, Kawu Sumaila, senator representing Kano central, said some factors cause the clashes between farmers and herders that have not been addressed.

“Let us come up with something more comprehensive that protects the interest of all parties,” Sumaila said.

“There are so many reasons why herders go against farmers that we should look at. It is against the constitution, and we will fight it to the end.”

Supporting the bill, Enyinnaya Abaribe, senator representing Abia south, said farmers in the country are under threat.

“This is the reason Nigeria is facing food insecurity,” Abaribe said.

Barau Jibrin, deputy senate president, said the bill should be stepped down for further consultation, but Zam refused to move a motion to that effect.

Thereafter, the bill was put to a vote, and the “ayes” were in the majority.

It was referred to the committees on agriculture, trade and investment, the judiciary, and legal matters.

These committees are expected to report back to the plenary within a month.

COMMENT: “Kicking against the bill, Kawu Sumaila, senator representing Kano central, said some factors cause the clashes between farmers and herders that have not been addressed.”

Did Sen Sumaila try to address those issues, especially as they pertain to Kano State?
Of course NOT. Why would he not allow the people of Benue to tell their own story, in their own words?

He and those who sent him simply wanted to put an end to the debate.

Many may not readily remember that even the much derided then Governor Abdullahi Umar Ganduje had not only embraced the ban on open grazing but had provided data indicating the capacity of Kano State to accommodate a huge percentage of Nigerian cattle now roaming in a destructive rampage. That publicly stated position was one of the high points of his stint as Governor of Kano – Oduche Azih.

---

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER NOW

Email address:

Leave this field empty if you're human:

---

Support MATAZ ARISING’ journalism of integrity and credibility.

Good journalism ensure the possibility of a good society, an accountable democracy, and a transparent government.

We ask you to consider making a modest support to this noble endeavour.

TEXT AD: To advertise here – Email ad@matazarising.com

LATEST POSTS